Who's That Knocking at My Door, Martin Scorsese's 1967 debut feature, marked the beginning of Scorsese's most lucrative partnership. It would be a few years before he'd hook up with Robert De Niro for Mean Streets (and, of course, a few decades until his current muse, Leonardo DiCaprio), and while Harvey Keitel, another Scorsese regular, makes his feature film debut here, all of these collaborations pale in comparison to the work editor Thelma Schoonmaker has done to bring Scorsese's unique vision to the screen. Granted, after Who's That Knocking at My Door and the editorial input they provided for Woodstock, the two never worked together during Scorsese's king-making days of the 1970s, but Schoonmaker returned for Raging Bull, whose boxing sequences in particular are some of the most stunning pieces of editing ever committed to the screen, and the two haven't parted since. (Well, for narrative features, at least. We'll get to one exception later.)
One of Scorsese's greatest strengths as a filmmaker is his ability to achieve a thrilling level of energy. This is not just in the high intensity of his action-based sequences, but his films have the rare ability to infuse life and motion into inanimate objects and still bodies. Schoonmaker is integral in this accomplishment. Her flair is particularly evident in one series of sequences that, while employing such flourishes as Godardian inserts and an extended fantasy sequence, always carries a sense of forward momentum. Schoonmaker connects these sequences through sound, graphic and thematic matches that suggest a stream-of-consciousness approach to the film's unfolding. After a seemingly random act of violence ends in gunshots, the sound carries over, with the gunshots punctuating a series of still images from classic westerns that give way to Keitel and his girlfriend leaving a movie theater showing Rio Bravo. The two discuss the film and when the conversation turns to a female character, Keitel describes her as a broad, defining the term with a sexually explicit fantasy sequence before jumping back into the conversation. Their strolls ends on Keitel and his girlfriend hailing a taxi, and the concluding close-up on the cab's door handle serves as a graphic match for the cut to the next scene, with Keitel and his friends driving upstate.
This series of sequences is typical of the film's narrative structure, and early Scorsese in general, where the development of a plot is of almost no importance compared to fleshing out characters and their surroundings. For his debut, Scorsese followed the “write what you know” mantra, with Keitel portraying a clear Scorsese avatar in J.R., a young, movie-obsessed Italian-American Catholic living in New York City. The film depicts J.R. and his friends as they pass the time either by hanging out in their usual dive, a dingy bar whose sparsely-decorated walls consist only of Playboy pin-ups and a picture of JFK, or venturing out into the streets and each others' apartments, where the activities generally turn to violence. When apart from this group, J.R. courts a girl he met while waiting for the Staten Island Ferry, and his wooing mainly involves conversations about movies, particularly John Wayne westerns. As the relationship grows deeper, J.R. wrestles with his Catholic upbringing, becoming unsure of how far he's willing to take the relationship. After the girl reveals that she was once raped, he also questions her purity.







